U.S.A. v. Beane
- Case Type:
- Business
- Case Status:
- Reversed and Remanded
- Citation:
- 15-15444 (11th Circuit, Nov 23,2016) Published
- Tag(s):
- Ruling:
Circuit court found that tax court never reached the issue as to interest due and owing for tax year 1998 because it did not have jurisdiction to do so. As such, it was not improper for the government to include interest in total amount due and owing for tax year 1998.
- Procedural context:
Case appealed from bankruptcy court to district court. District court affirmed bankruptcy court's ruling. Parties later entered into partial settlement agreement but reserve issues related to interest due for underpayment of taxes and bankruptcy court issued a certification for direct appeal to Circuit Court. Circuit accepted direct appeal.
- Facts:
Debtor owed interest due to underpayment of taxes for tax year 1998. Tax court issued a determination as to deficiency amount due for tax year 1998 but did not include a determination of interest owed. Government later included interest in total amount due for tax year 1998. Debtor objected to calculation and bankruptcy determined that tax court decision was final and determinative of amounts owed for tax year 1998 and that it was improper for government to include interest in calculation of amounts due and owing because such amounts were not determined by the tax court.
- Judge(s):
- Tjoflat, Hull and Mendoza